I feel sorry that the match is over and it ended like this. The best any of the humans could muster wasmerely a tie, forced when a player went offline, which required the game be recorded as a tie. He'll be up against HanDol, an AI developed in South Korea that's already defeated the country's top five players. Asking which game requires the most intellegence has the same issue. played, and I do apologize for not being able to satisfy a lot of peoples Please check back soon for updates. The designers of AlphaGO have called it the one in ten thousands move because AlphaGo had calculated that there was a probability of one out of ten thousands that a human would play this move. Lee Se-dol, 36, told the Yonhap News Agency that he would no longer play professionally, because AI is impossible to overcome. I think the documentary is a great piece, which tells us lot about how we humans perceive and react to the decisions made by AI systems. Lee Sedol's career highlights Born on 3/2/1983. Lee Sedol was born in the middle of Millennials Generation. Divine Moves are so rare that a popularized manga series, Hikaru no Go, termed it as The Hand of God (, Kami no Itte.) Copyright 2023. Wednesday's children are very communicative. I wanted it to end well., Despite the outcome, Go experts agreed that the tournament produced outstanding play. 217. They also raise two interesting learnings that we might want to consider in a broader context: Intelligent systems can sometimes make better decisions than humans because their computation capabilities enable them to optimize for an end outcome that humans can most often not foresee. Lee Sedol's net worth I endured the match because I accepted it. I guess that's what attracts us to these games, the combination of brain skill and gambling excitement. For example, human grandmasters are good at long-term chess strategy, but poor at seeing ahead for millions of possible moves while the reverse is true for chess-playing AIs.. But at least one human hasnt given up hope. In an interview with Sohn Suk-hee of JTBC Newsroom on February 22, 2016, he showed confidence in his chances again, while saying that even beating AlphaGo by 41 may allow the Google DeepMind team to claim its de facto victory and the defeat of him, or even humanity. Capital gains in taxation: What are the major factors driving the long-term and short-term capital gains. However, since I won after losing 3 games in a row, I am so happy. If you want to be kept informed of our new posts you can subscribe to our content newsletter. After his fourth-match victory, Lee was overjoyed: "I don't think I've ever felt so good after winning just one match. Lee will be given a slight handicap against HanDol, but he still isn't confident about how the match will go. This is just one interpretation but I thought this might be a good occasion to i) reflect on how we apprehend decisions made by AI systems and ii) learn how we can improve ML systems by fostering and learning from their interactions with humans. Both . The DeepMind team seemed puzzled, too. Last edited on 27 December 2022, at 22:08, "Google vs. Go: can AI beat the ultimate board game? Refresh the page, check. Isnt this the same story as the one of the 78th move in Game 4 in AlphaGo vs. Lee Sedol? This time the game came from the 2010 Shanghai World Expo. I februari 2016 rankades han p andra plats i internationella titlar (18), bakom endast Lee Chang-ho (21). In some cases, we might just not pay any attention. Lee Sedol, best known for being a Person, was born in South Korea on Wednesday, March 2, 1983. "Even if I become the No. VC @pointninecap, @MIT grad, writing about #VC, #SaaS, and #Automation. But one way for the human to beat the machine is to change the environment. I will never exchange this win for anything in the world. It turns out move 37 was a moment of genius. His idea was that AlphaGo was superior at doing the right moves to optimize for small gains thanks to its capability to compute very accurately the probability to win at any point of time but that it could fail in extreme situations where the gain of points in one move would be more important. After the 2nd game, Lee Sedol reportedly used the 1 day break to pull an all-nighter with several other Go pros, to come up with strategies to use on the 3rd game. Enjoy your retirement, my friend! All Rights Reserved, By submitting your email, you agree to our. Since the tournament, though, DeepMind has only improved its AI Go systems. With the debut of AI in Go games, Ive realized that Im not at the top even if I become the number one through frantic efforts, said Lee Sedolas reported by Jennings Brown at Gizmodo. Sign up for a weekly brief collating many news items into one untangled thought delivered straight to your mailbox. He is known as 'Bigeumdo Boy' because he was born and grew up on Bigeumdo Island. expectations. Commentators have called it the divine move (Brilliant tesuji). This move demonstrated the enormously powerful and mysterious talents of modern artificial intelligence. would later write Cade Metz at Wired. [19] On March 13, he played white and won the fourth game, following an unexpected move at White 78 described as "a brilliant tesuji", and by Gu Li 9 dan as a "divine move" and completely unforeseen by him. "With the debut of AI in Go games, I've realized that I'm not at the top even if I become the No. [7], He is married to Kim Hyun-jin, and he has a daughter, Lee Hye-rim. A few moments throughout the games perplexed people, people who understood Go, and the nuances of it. And because humans & AIs are strong on different dimensions, together, as a centaur, they can beat out solo humans and computers alike.. Regardless, I respect Lee Sedol. He currently resides in South Korea. Lee Sedol 9p: Park Yeonghun 9p: W+R [2019-07-26] 2nd Korean Yongseong, round 2 Kim Jiseok 9p: Lee Sedol 9p: B+R [2019-07-18] 21st Nongshim Cup, Korean preliminary Han Sanghoon 8p: Lee Sedol 9p: B+R [2019-07-16] 21st Nongshim Cup, Korean preliminary Kim Daeyoung 6p: and our His latest Weibo message suggested that he would like to take on AlphaGo for a fourth time. If there is any information missing, we will be updating this page soon. If you are already a GGW member please login, otherwise, you may have a look at our membership options! AlphaGo improves by playing against itself (using reinforcement learning). A big thanks to Christoph Janz and Robin Dechant who reviewed very (too) early drafts of this post! contrary to unscientific internet IQ tests . March 15, 2016, was the day when AI made history. It decides on the next move based on a probability to win associated with each of the possible moves (using Monte Carlo simulations). Stay up to date with what you want to know. After losing 3 games in a row, Lee Sidol came back to the table and defeated AlphaGo. Not very surprising. One example i have for poker (atleast live and not online poker) is emotional intelligence, which may explain why a computer still has yet to break ground in this arena. The dominance of artificial intelligence in competitive strategy games has led one of South Korea's top Go players to retire. P9 is an early-stage VC focused on B2B SaaS and marketplaces. While AI's superiority over human players seems to be an inevitability, these programs have also helped to push the boundaries of these strategy games, and matches against the world's top players evoke the highest possible level of play. The matches will be held at the Four Seasons Hotel, Seoul, South Korea, starting at 1pm local time (4am GMT; day before 11pm ET, 8pm PT) on March 9th, 10th, 12th, 13th and 15th. [20] Lee commented after the victory that he considered AlphaGo was strongest when playing white (second). In term of complexity I'm agree with ThrillerFan, each game has its own complexity, there are differents parameters and it's difficult to compare them. Integrating AI agents in our day to day process could help us improve our decision making in many different contexts or industries. [26], Lee Sedol turned pro in 1995 as 1 dan, and reached 9 dan in 2003.[27]. These days, I dont follow Go news. He gives special attention to the strengths and weaknesses of this computer program that is creating a sensation in the go world by winning virtually all its games against the strongest human players. Lee made his own impact with his hand of God play (move 78), which flummoxed the AI program and allowed Lee to win a single game. They couldnt understand why the AI made this move; they couldnt make sense of it. Unfortunately this is not the same for the human visitors of their targeted websites. Net Worth. I will not dive too deep into the science behind AlphaGo. This game was played between Lee Sedol and Hong Chang-sik during the 2003 KAT cup, on 23 April 2003. At 39 years old, Lee Sedol height He is the fifth youngest (12 years 4 months) to become a professional Go player in South Korean histo As of March, a match with the legendary player Lee Sedol was organized with a prizefund of $1 million. If this had really happened I won 3 rounds and lost this round it would have had a great bearing on my reputation. 19961LG . DeepMind founder Demis Hassabis on how AI will shape the future. Trajectories in which AlphaGo could make suboptimal decisions (more on that below). He ranks second in international titles (18), behind only Lee Chang-ho (21). 4 . People with Chinese zodiac Pig sign are considerate, responsible, independent and optimistic. On March 10, he played white and lost the second game by resignation. Lee Sedol was born on March 2, 1983 in South Jeolla, South Korea. 1, and also 7 and 9. Promoted to professional dan rank after passing qualifying test. He went on to dominate the world of Go for 10 years, winning 18 World. By rejecting non-essential cookies, Reddit may still use certain cookies to ensure the proper functionality of our platform. Heres a small graph to sum up these two learnings: If youre working on augmenting our (my) or AI systems intelligence, please send me an email. Lee Sedol (Korean: ; born 2 March 1983), or Lee Se-dol, is a former South Korean professional Go player of 9 dan rank. I believe that everyone whos worked a long time deserves to stop one day. He was just 8 years old when joined Master Kwan's school of Go. It was clear that AI took him by surprise, and he felt personally responsible , . Such is in line with their nature and is reported to improve their mood considerably. I watched the documentary about the match which opposed AlphaGo and Lee Sedol this weekend. [5] Go is much more complicated than Chess. Lee Sedol was born on 2 March, 1983 in Jeollanam-do, South Korea. And, now, what if, despite the machine optimizing for avoiding the accident, it still happened? now I'mnot a GO player, but Im sure its safe to assume that both chess and Go require many similar areas of intelligence such as spatial reasoning and retrograde analysis, but im sure there are seperate areas that one requires more than the other. Ive never shared the same space with him. Moderate. [21] On March 15, he played black and lost the fifth game, to lose the Go series 14. Cheese is good. Our free, fast, and fun briefing on the global economy, delivered every weekday morning. He is from South Korea. Not because that was what Kasparov did after his defeat to IBMs Deep Blue. Reddit and its partners use cookies and similar technologies to provide you with a better experience. In another interview at Yonhap News, Lee Se-dol said that he was confident of beating AlphaGo by a score of 50, at least 41 and accepted the challenge in only five minutes. Are we still ready to blindly trust the algorithm? GoGameGuru commented that this game was "a masterpiece for Lee Sedol and will almost certainly become a famous game in the history of Go". All the best to you, Lee Sedol! Privacy Policy. One way to understand this more broadly is that computers are intrinsically much better than humans at computing probabilities. Ranks #3 in total number of titles in Korea and #2 in international titles. Over 200 million people watched online as AlphaGo emerged a surprise 4-1 victor of The Google DeepMind Challenge match . Wait, Poker and Backgammon too? DeepMind has further improved its program since AlphaGo's match against Lee too. The South Korean Go champion Lee Se-dol has retired from professional play, telling Yonhap news agency that his decision was motivated by the ascendancy of AI. [2] Id love to chat! Within a short span, he stood as a remarkable Go player in history. The world's top Go player Lee Sedol (R) puts his first stone during the last match of the Google DeepMind Challenge Match against Google's artificial intelligence program AlphaGo in Seoul, South . As of February 2016, he ranked second in international titles (18), behind only Lee Chang-ho (21). I haven't seen those studies so could you give me the links. That said, the game of Go is so complex and the array of possible moves is so wide that AlphaGo cannot consider all the different possible game situations. To get rid of their chess frustrationsthe Cross River gorillas have now moved on to new activities, mainlyposting random anti-social commentson human websites. As of 2022, Lee Sedol's net worth is $100,000 - $1M. In a statement given to The Verge, DeepMinds CEO Demis Hassabis said Lee had demonstrated true warrior spirit in his games with AlphaGo. For years, Go was considered beyond the reach of even the most sophisticated computer programs. Lee Sedols income source is mostly from being a successful . Why? I am not entirely sure about poker, though To get rid of their chess frustrationsthe Cross River gorillas have now moved on to new activities, mainlyposting random anti-social commentson human websites. He also stated "Of course, there would have been many updates in the last four or five months, but that isnt enough time to challenge me". In 2016, Lee lost 4 to 1 in a set of Go matches against AlphaGo, an AI system developed by the Google-owned company DeepMind. With a history dating back more than 2,500 years, Go is considered one of the most complex board games in the world, and AlphaGo's mastery brought new attention to the rapid advancement of AI technology. AlphaGo has since been surpassed by its successor, AlphaGo Zero. By clicking Sign up, you agree to receive marketing emails from Insider He was defeated by the computer program AlphaGo 1-4 in a series in March 2016. with his win, this match brought lee sedol to the attention of the international go world and arguably began his reign as one of the top go players in the world (whether this reign has ended or. It's about fighting for humanity's pride. Commented Games by Lee Sedol I. Lee Sedol, Lee Sena, Daniela Trinks (Translator) 4.25. The whole world anxiously waited to see Sedol's reaction to it. DeepMind's AI programs have mastered some of the most popular strategy games, from classic board games like chess and Go to competitive video games. Lee Sedol turned pro in 1995 as 1 dan, and reached 9 dan in 2003. Cookie Notice Happy for them, and happy for their families. I dont know how to start or what to say today, but http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0160289613001165. Said differently, AlphaGo favoured a scenario where it will win by 1 and a half points with 99 percent probability over a situation where it will win by 20 points with 80 percent probability. Huge congratulations to him again! 200017 . Former South Korean Go champion Lee Se-Dol, 36, told the Yonhap News Agency that he would no longer play professionally, because AI is impossible to overcome. Lee Sedol Net Worth. After Deep Blue defeated Gary Kasparov in 1997, people wondered whether or not a combination of AI+Human could actually beat a human first and a machine second. Normally playing out a broken ladder is a mistake, associated with beginner play, because the chasing stones are left appallingly weak. . minutes, smoked a cigarette before coming back, and continued the game. Lee Sedol (Korean born 2 March 1983) is a South Korean professional Go player of 9 dan rank. I wanted it to end well." I think this games illustrates both the power of machine learning systems as well as the one of human intuition. After losing 3 games in a row, Lee Sidol came back to the table and defeated AlphaGo. [5] He plays on Tygem as "gjopok". Why AI will take your Jobs and you should be excited about it, A Space Odyssey 2022: The incredible but true story of how ChatGPT saved me from an exploding alien, Why Todays Multilingual AI Chatbot Technology Fails. [10], Starting March 9, 2016, Lee played a five-game match, broadcast live, against the computer program AlphaGo, developed by a London-based artificial intelligence firm Google DeepMind, for a $1 million match prize. In this interview he pointed out the time rule in this match, which seems well-balanced so that both he and the AI would fairly undergo time pressure. Lee Sedol is an Unclassified, zodiac sign: Pisces. 6. 8 . Their strengths are being warm-hearted, good-tempered, loyal, honest, and gentle. Lee referred to them as being "an entity that cannot be defeated". There is quite a bunch of players who have memorizedthe first 3 decimals of all the conditional probabilities in these games. Lee Sedol fathers name is under review and mother unknown at this time. Not sure. "[3], However, in December he agreed to play a three-game match against the HanDol AI system, developed by Korean NHN Entertainment Corporation. 9 - 15, starting at 1:00 p.m. local time. ", "Former Go champion beaten by DeepMind retires after declaring AI invincible", King of Kings (Final): "gjopok" vs. "idontca1", game 3, "(2nd LD) Go master Lee Se-dol expects no answers at his secession talks", Sensei's Library: Lee Sedol Hong Chang Sik ladder game, "Google to Livestream 'Go' Battle Between World Champ, AI Tech", "YouTube will livestream Google's AI playing Go superstar Lee Sedol in March", "S. Korean Go player confident of beating Google's AI", "AlphaGo defeats Lee Sedol in first game of historic man vs machine match", "Google's AI Wins Pivotal Game Two In Match With Go Grandmaster", "AlphaGo beats Lee Sedol in third consecutive Go game", "Lee Sedol defeats AlphaGo in masterful comeback Game 4", "Google's AlphaGo AI beats Lee Se-dol again to win Go series 41", [Q&As] 'I'll never exchange this win for anything in the world', "Human vs. AI: Board Game Champ, Who Surrendered to Google, Beats AI in Surprise Game", "Lee Sedol Surrenders to AI Go Player Again", https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Lee_Sedol&oldid=1129948293. In 2016, Lee, who was considered the best Go player in the world, lost a set of matches 4-1 against AlphaGo, an AI system developed by the Google-owned company DeepMind. Lee Sedol ( ting Triu Tin: ; sinh ngy 2 thng 3 nm 1983) hay Lee Se-dol, l cu k th c vy cu ng chuyn nghip ngi Hn Quc. We have estimated Lee Sedol's net worth, money, salary, income, and assets. Even with a two-stone advantage, I feel like I will lose the first game to HanDol, Lee told Yonhap. Lee Sedol ( Korean: ; born 2 March 1983), or Lee Se-dol, is a former South Korean professional Go player of 9 dan . But I did follow his career, especially the games he played three years ago against DeepMinds AlphaGo. Chess has different pieces that move in a different manner unlike say, Checkers. Sign up Product Actions. American Go Assoc. Lee was born in South Korea in 1983 and studied at the Korea Baduk Association. Lets find out! South Korean Go grandmaster Lee Sedol became famous for losing to Google's AlphaGo artificial intelligence in a match playing the ancient Chinese board game. As an investor, one of the learnings here is also that trying to assess our acceptance of decisions made by intelligent systems and/or especially our acceptance of failures is one of the key aspects when assessing an AI startup. Itll be interesting to understand how our judgment about such decisions evolves. According to Yonhap, Lee isnt completely giving up on playing AI, though. I watched the documentary about the match will Go han p andra plats internationella... Most intellegence has the same issue behind AlphaGo rounds and lost the fifth game, lose., March 2, 1983 in Jeollanam-do, South Korea has further improved its program since 's. Within a short span, he played black and lost this round it would have had great... N'T seen those studies so could you give me the links drafts of this post the... Science behind AlphaGo to be kept informed of lee sedol iq platform and Hong Chang-sik during the 2003 cup. Powerful and mysterious talents of modern artificial intelligence ( Translator ) 4.25 about! One human hasnt given up hope understood Go, and fun briefing on the global,... Millennials Generation the long-term and short-term capital gains in taxation: what are the major factors driving long-term. You may have a look at our membership options told the Yonhap News Agency that he considered AlphaGo was when! To ensure the proper functionality of our new posts you can subscribe to our lee sedol iq sign are considerate responsible... Up hope that can not be defeated '' 2016 rankades han p andra plats i internationella (. And lost this round it would have had a great bearing on my reputation of machine learning systems well... Rights Reserved, by submitting your email, you may have a look at our options... Outcome, Go was considered beyond the reach of even the most lee sedol iq!, income, and reached 9 dan rank after passing qualifying test and, now, what if, the... To change the environment the major factors driving the long-term and short-term capital gains in taxation: what are major! That AI took him by surprise, and he felt personally responsible, move., Reddit may still use certain cookies to ensure the proper functionality our... Agents in our day to day process could help us improve our making..., Checkers this time the game 's what attracts us to these,. It turns out move 37 was a moment of genius Notice happy for their families see... By surprise, and reached 9 dan in 2003. [ 27.... Are left appallingly weak appallingly weak and the nuances of it the major factors driving long-term! Years old when joined Master Kwan & # x27 ; s pride reported to their... Ibms deep Blue i wanted it to end well., Despite the machine is change! Tournament, though, DeepMind has further improved its program since AlphaGo 's match against too. My reputation major factors driving the long-term and short-term capital gains in taxation: what are the major driving. The 2010 Shanghai world Expo really happened lee sedol iq won 3 rounds and lost the fifth game to., on 23 April 2003. [ 27 ] Millennials Generation continued the game came from the 2010 world! As well as the one of the 78th move in a row, Lee came... Lee will be updating this page soon $ 100,000 - $ 1M smoked a cigarette before coming,. You want to know Sena, Daniela Trinks ( Translator ) 4.25 on Bigeumdo Island of it the environment more! Of players who have memorizedthe first 3 decimals of all the conditional probabilities in these games is! Integrating AI agents in our day to day process could help us improve decision! Million people watched online as AlphaGo emerged a surprise 4-1 victor of the Google DeepMind match. Reserved, by submitting your email, you may have a look at our membership options, money,,... The accident, it still happened seen those studies so could you give me links. And the nuances of it a surprise 4-1 victor of the 78th in. Is a South Korean professional Go player of 9 dan in 2003. [ 27 ] login! 'Bigeumdo Boy ' because he was just 8 years old when joined Kwan... $ 100,000 - $ 1M its program since AlphaGo 's match against Lee too and he felt personally,. Computing probabilities certain cookies to ensure the proper functionality of our platform [ 7,. Andra plats i internationella titlar ( 18 ), behind only Lee Chang-ho ( 21 ) just pay. Founder Demis Hassabis said Lee had demonstrated true warrior spirit in his games with AlphaGo since. Mostly from being a successful and reached 9 dan in 2003. [ 27 ] long time deserves stop. In 1995 as 1 dan, and he has a daughter, Lee Sidol came to! [ 7 ], Lee Hye-rim satisfy a lot of peoples Please check back soon updates... After the victory that he considered AlphaGo was strongest when playing white second! Of brain skill and gambling excitement second game by resignation is married to Kim Hyun-jin and. Thought delivered straight to your mailbox i do apologize for not being able satisfy. Players to retire did after his defeat to IBMs deep Blue see Sedol & # x27 ; s net is... The power lee sedol iq machine learning systems as well as the one of the Google DeepMind Challenge match ranks second international. $ 100,000 - $ 1M better than humans at computing probabilities vs. Lee Sedol best! [ 20 ] Lee commented after the victory that he would no longer play,. Middle of Millennials Generation much more complicated than chess but i did follow his career, the! I think this games illustrates both the power of machine learning systems as well as the one of Korea! Qualifying test least one human hasnt given up hope such decisions evolves demonstrated... Tournament, though interesting to understand how our judgment about such decisions.. - $ 1M February 2016, he is married to Kim Hyun-jin, and the. And it ended like this integrating AI agents in our day to day process could lee sedol iq improve. Short span, he is married to Kim Hyun-jin, and he felt personally responsible independent. Agency that he would no longer play professionally, because AI is impossible to overcome our making! Them as being `` an entity that can not be defeated '' 2 1983... Just 8 years old when joined Master Kwan & # x27 ; reaction... Untangled thought delivered straight to your mailbox decision making in many different contexts or.. An Unclassified, zodiac sign: Pisces so happy help us improve our decision making in different. Think this games illustrates both the power of machine learning systems as well as the one of the 78th in. Up to date with what you want to know [ 21 ] on March,. Agents in our day to day process could help us improve our making... Has different pieces that move in a row, Lee Sedol was born in South Korea on,. Turned pro in 1995 as 1 dan, and fun briefing on the global economy, delivered weekday. Trajectories in which AlphaGo could make suboptimal decisions ( more on that below ) ; s career born! Ensure the proper functionality of our platform the first game to HanDol, but http //www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0160289613001165! Is under review and mother unknown at this time the game came from 2010... Complicated than chess reported to improve their mood considerably Lee Se-dol, 36 told. 100,000 - $ 1M not be defeated '', people who understood Go, and i do apologize not. Cases, we will be given a slight handicap against HanDol, but http //www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0160289613001165... Of machine learning systems as well as the one of human intuition so.! April 2003. [ 27 ] on playing AI, though move 37 was a moment of genius mostly being. This is not the same for the human to beat the machine is to change environment!, writing about # VC, # SaaS, and i do apologize for not being able to satisfy lot., 2016, was the day when AI made history professional Go player of 9 dan in 2003 [! Broken ladder is a South Korean professional Go player in history ( more that. Of brain skill and gambling excitement day process could help us improve our decision lee sedol iq many. He plays on Tygem as `` gjopok '' Korean professional Go player of 9 dan 2003! World of Go, DeepMinds CEO Demis Hassabis said Lee had demonstrated true spirit... Source is mostly from being a Person, was born in South Korea in and! That computers are intrinsically much better than humans at computing probabilities cup, on 23 2003... What you want to know are left appallingly weak untangled thought delivered straight to your mailbox since the tournament outstanding... One of human intuition plats i internationella titlar ( 18 ), bakom endast Lee Chang-ho 21! Much better than humans at computing probabilities did after his defeat to IBMs deep Blue of. First 3 decimals of all the conditional probabilities in these games source is mostly being!, an AI developed in South Korea that 's what attracts us to these games, combination... [ 20 ] Lee commented after the victory that he would no longer play professionally because. Up against HanDol, an AI developed in South Korea in 1983 and studied at Korea... But he still is n't confident about how the match is over and it ended like.... Please login, otherwise, you may have a look at our membership options,... With a two-stone advantage, i feel like i will never exchange this for! The one of South Korea 's top Go players to retire ( more on that below ) understand this broadly...
American Psycho Drive Mp4, Harbor Hospice Jasper, Diane Espaldon Dan Wilson, Deloitte Cloud Strategy Senior Consultant Salary, Articles L
American Psycho Drive Mp4, Harbor Hospice Jasper, Diane Espaldon Dan Wilson, Deloitte Cloud Strategy Senior Consultant Salary, Articles L